2.i, Carumbus ✓ «ULTIMATE»

Reviewers generally praise the episode for its cohesive storytelling, opting for a singular, long-form narrative rather than the typical three-story anthology style. It is frequently cited as one of the more "impressive" entries of the modern era.

: The story traces the rise and fall of Obeseus the Wide (Homer) in Ancient Rome. Critics noted that the pacing felt assured and the narrative structure was solid, avoiding "cheap side quests" that often clutter recent episodes. 2.I, Carumbus

: While some felt it lacked a final "oomph" or "blatant evisceration" of its historical subject, others appreciated the subtle subversion and meta-commentary, particularly the closing scene featuring the Greek gods. Human Perspectives Reviewers generally praise the episode for its cohesive

“I thought there would be a bit in it about how Obeseus became fat, but that wasn't really touched on, which didn't bother me.” The No Homers Club · 5 years ago Critics noted that the pacing felt assured and

Better than most modern parodies but still felt slightly hit-or-miss. The Simpsons Season 32 Episode 2 Review: I, Carumbus

The following perspectives from the community highlight the episode's reception among long-time fans: