[s1e20] What Is And What Should Never Be -

While hunting a (a genie-like creature), Dean Winchester is attacked and transported into a "wish-fulfillment" alternate reality. In this world: Mary Winchester (his mother) is alive and well.

Michelle Borth appears as Carmen, Dean’s girlfriend in the alternate reality. Trivia & Lore [S1E20] What Is And What Should Never Be

Dean is initially overjoyed by this normal life, but he soon realizes the cost. Without the Winchesters as hunters, all the people they saved in the real world have died. Dean eventually decides to reject the fantasy, even as his "dream family" begs him to stay, and wakes himself up by attempting suicide within the dream. Director: Eric Kripke Writer: Raelle Tucker While hunting a (a genie-like creature), Dean Winchester