[s2e7] - Whodunnit

The episode is widely viewed as "entertainingly bad." It leaned heavily into the ridiculousness of its premise, which worked for those who enjoy the show's guilty-pleasure edge, but alienated those looking for a fair or scientific mystery.

Community feedback highlights a significant shift in tone. Fans on IMDb and Reddit criticized the inconsistent judging, noting that decisions felt forced to push certain storylines rather than rewarding the best investigators. [S2E7] Whodunnit

“Part of this show's appeal for me is that even the bad episodes are entertaining, and I thought this was one of those entertainingly bad episodes.” Reddit · r/gameshow · 12 years ago The episode is widely viewed as "entertainingly bad

This episode centered on a complex "crime of the week" that left many viewers frustrated by the lack of clear clues. Critics noted that the "A-ha!" moments felt unearned, as the answers often seemed to come from flashes of inspiration rather than logical deduction. “Part of this show's appeal for me is