: The "case of the week" was criticized by some as the weakest part of the hour, described as "pretty boring" with a "cheesy" villain.
This episode is essential for viewers following the long-term arc of , as it marks a turning point where Ben begins to choose his feelings for Alice over his loyalty to the Kensington Firm. The Catch: Season 1, Episode 5 - Rotten Tomatoes
: Alice and Rose represent Rene, a high-powered city attorney being blackmailed by businessman Tony Ellis. The blackmail involves a past indiscretion of Rene's husband, William, who allegedly had an affair with a student when he was a young teacher. The Catch 1x5
: Under pressure from their mysterious benefactor, Margot and Ben are tasked with a $15 million jewelry heist to repay their mounting debts. Critical Reception
Critics and viewers have mixed but generally positive views on this installment: : The "case of the week" was criticized
: The romance between the lead pair heats up as Ben texts Alice to meet. However, Agent Dao is monitoring the call, leading to a tense scene where both Ben and Alice spot him at the meeting point and have to pivot.
: Reviewers from Vulture noted that Alice and Ben became more multi-layered in this episode, moving beyond their initial "stoic investigator" and "slick con man" archetypes. The blackmail involves a past indiscretion of Rene's
: The episode is praised for its "Shondaland" production qualities—stylish, fast-paced, and full of plot twists—though some IMDb reviewers found the episode a bit "safe" compared to grittier crime dramas. Should You Watch It?